I meant legally challenged. I challenged it myself when I was teaching Bikeability, but I was told (albeit more politely) to put up or shut up. I was aware of a couple of people who had been told that they were not allowed to teach Bikeability for the local authority because of their refusal to wear a helmet or enforce helmet-wearing. One of them started their own company, and had just gotten round to hiring other teachers when I moved.pjclinch wrote: ↑22 May 2024, 10:42amThis is, indeed, the case.Vorpal wrote: ↑22 May 2024, 9:57amBikeability doesn't require helmets, though.cycle tramp wrote: ↑15 May 2024, 10:04pm
I'm pretty sure that branches the current laws of diversity - indeed I'm surprised that bikeability haven't been threatened with legal action.
It's mainly the schools & local authorities that do.
I know for a fact I've challenged it, but despite coming at it with evidence and bloody-mindedness it's really slow progress. When I put it to Cycling Scotland over a decade ago that they ought to emphasise that their Bikeability Scotland course didn't require helmets I had a good conversation with Christopher Johnson of CS where he said he was broadly in agreement with all my points but what he was being paid to do was to create a course that would have maximum uptake across Scotland, and if it specifically stated helmets were an optional extra then various LAs where delivery was in the hands of ex Police old-school RSOs wouldn't touch it with a 10 foot bargepole. So his remit required him to avoid the issue, and in the circumstances I think that was a reasonable choice.
But things have progressed a bit. For example, the Bikeability Scotland resources now feature kids riding in just their normal clothes/school uniforms rather than dayglo tabards for everything, and looking at pictures of actual delivery this has spilled over in to standard practice. That's quite significant as a culture change. And the last time we had a resource update and call for comments I penned my usual essay on helmets, this time majoring on inclusiveness, and on the back of that was a call for images of unhelmeted riding. That would have been unthinkable back when I started chipping away at it.
I'm glad that things have progressed in Scotland. They don't seem to have where I used to live.