SA_SA_SA wrote:mjr wrote:....As I understand it, it's assuming no focusing optics or even reflector - definitely not anything as fancy as white-vs-red lumens - and that you want 4cd showing to the side as well as "to the rear" as required by the current regs. You could maybe halve that with a reflector, depending on any case law about interpreting "to the rear", ....
Well The 4cd in BS6102/3 only seems to the brightest 'central' point A, [...] I would interpret the 4cd law on sole rear flashers as meaning a lamps minimum centralish intensity is 4cd and relying on the light source not being a laser for the surrounding smaller values specified in BS
Good for you! But I stand by my advice because while we might hope that the 4cd added to the regulations (in 2005 I think) might be interpreted like the measurement in the British Standard, we don't yet know that (and I suspect we won't for a long time, with the state of roads policing), so I'd play it safe and go for 50 lumens if you're buying the sort of rear light whose strength is stated in lumens (which might well suffer from overstating like those "10,000 lumen" front lights), or I guess maybe 25 if you're reasonably confident there's some sort of half-decent reflector or lens on it.