661-Pete wrote:This debate about Naz Shah appears to have been initiated solely to deflect argument away from criticism of the current Tory regime. If that's what some on this forum want, so be it. I find that deplorable.
It's an open forum,but as I posted earlier it's a classic whataboutery tactic by Tory supporters in an effort to divert attention focus away from the subject in hand.
Looking at the article in which Shah admits to, and apologises for, what she refers to as anti-semitism, I note two incidents. In one, she is said to have superimposed a map of Israel on the map of the USA, with the caption
"Solution for Israel-Palestine conflict - relocate Israel into United States". In the other she is alleged to have likened Israeli policies to the Nazis.
Both of these actions are, I agree, highly insulting to Israel/quote]
Nowt wrong in that then.
and to Israelis: even those who don't support Netanyahu's expanionist policies
Not necessarily,more about Israel's foreign policy to turf out the Palistinians frommtheir own country,does it remind you of another regeme that proliferated for a short time in the middle of part of the last century.
I think the insults are somewhat OTT, albeit understandable. But anti-semitic? Marginally so, in my view
I disagree
since these are direct attacks on Israel rather than Jews in general. And the Israeli regime (which many Israelis don't support) has done its fair share of insults and ill-treatment - directed at the Palestinians
That'll be about right IMO
Anyway, back to Naz Shah. I do not think she hates Jews. She may well hate Israelis - although perhaps she should look at the wide spread of public opinion - some of it humanitarian and sympathetic to Palestinians - amongst Israelis themselves
IMO it's the Israeli regeme she hates not individual Israelis.
None of us are perfect.
Incidentally, I don't need any lessons on what is anti-semitism, please - not from anyone on this forum! I admit to a fair knowledge of the subject
I think most people on the forum are fully aware the persecution of the Jews in WW2 and indeed before.
And yes there have been anti-semites within the Labour party - and other parties. There are always going to be some...
As there are within any section of society whatever party or club they belong to!
Perhaps it's better to draw a line under the antisemitism repetition by carpetcleaner and concentrate on BoJo and his diabolical government.