Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
-
- Posts: 2750
- Joined: 7 Jan 2008, 4:16pm
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
I would keep the msr and buy a Hilleberg Black Label tent. The msr is a US style inner first tent with a lot of mesh, i.e. a hot weather tent. Keep it for that. A Hilleberg or Helsport is a tent for nw European bad weather with hard winds and rain. With your kind of usage I would go for a Black Label tent. Choose a free standing one if you expect a lot of snow and or rocky terrain as at high altitudes. If not, go for a tunnel as these are more spacious and lighter.
-
- Posts: 225
- Joined: 14 Nov 2015, 7:20am
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
willem jongman wrote:I would keep the msr and buy a Hilleberg Black Label tent. The msr is a US style inner first tent with a lot of mesh, i.e. a hot weather tent. Keep it for that. A Hilleberg or Helsport is a tent for nw European bad weather with hard winds and rain. With your kind of usage I would go for a Black Label tent. Choose a free standing one if you expect a lot of snow and or rocky terrain as at high altitudes. If not, go for a tunnel as these are more spacious and lighter.
Hi willem - thanks for the reply.
The MSR has been used in cold temps quite effectively. When i arrived in the Netherlands last May and headed North, I was getting low single digit temps overnight. A good sleeping pad and bag are more important imho in dealing with the cold than the actual tent.
Yes, the MSR is great in the summer, but unfortunately, you still get rain in the summer in many locations and the wet weather is the main issue with my Hubba Hubba.....in particular the fly not being effective any more and touching the inner when wet.
Are there any other brands you could suggest that I look at at other than the Hille or Helsport?
I'm looking for a freestander for sure
Thanks again for your help!
-
- Posts: 2750
- Joined: 7 Jan 2008, 4:16pm
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
Single digits is not necessessarily really cold, and of course there is an overlap zone. As for the MSR, Hilleberg recommend Nikwax Solar Proof to treat older silicon coated tents. Our Nammatj 3GT is getting on, and I now treat it once a year with the Nikwax product, with good effect. I guess it would help with your tent, even though sagging outers are to some extent inevitable. You will need to use the guylines, even with a new tent, if you want to avoid condensation in your inner, because that may well be what it is.
As for bombproof bad weather tents, I think Hilleberg and Helsport are the two premier brands.
As for bombproof bad weather tents, I think Hilleberg and Helsport are the two premier brands.
Last edited by willem jongman on 26 Aug 2018, 2:25pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
I have two 2/3 person tents that I currently use. One is a Vango Spectre 300 (which is no longer made, but similar to the Banshee). The other is a Helsport.
The Vango, I bought it used off this forum & have been reasonably happy with it. We've never been wet in some pretty bad weather. We have had a little condensation a few times, which could be problematic with continuous wet weather. I have mainly used it camping with my kids (who are now 12 &9).
The Helsport is a two person tent (I think it's a Fjellheim, but I'm not sure about that). I love it. It weighs half as much, even though it's 2/3rds the size), it goes up more easily, and the fabric seems more durable. I would have said that the HelSport was not ventilated as well as the Vango, but we've never had any condensation in it. The poles are better, on the HelSport, too. We have a couple of slightly bent poles on the Vango, though they don't seem to affect the structure.
I have woken up cold a couple of times in the Vango. I have never woken up cold in the Helsport. It seems to hold body heat better. I've used both tents on pretty cold nights; well into single digits, though I don't know exact temperatures. I've not been camping in winter conditions in recent years.
The only disadvantage of the HelSport is that it is hotter on a warm summer day. I don't spend much time in it on a warm sunny day, so that doesn't bother me particularly. It could be a significant disadvantage to someone who likes to have lay-ins
If I were buying a new tent, I'd get another Helsport.
The Vango, I bought it used off this forum & have been reasonably happy with it. We've never been wet in some pretty bad weather. We have had a little condensation a few times, which could be problematic with continuous wet weather. I have mainly used it camping with my kids (who are now 12 &9).
The Helsport is a two person tent (I think it's a Fjellheim, but I'm not sure about that). I love it. It weighs half as much, even though it's 2/3rds the size), it goes up more easily, and the fabric seems more durable. I would have said that the HelSport was not ventilated as well as the Vango, but we've never had any condensation in it. The poles are better, on the HelSport, too. We have a couple of slightly bent poles on the Vango, though they don't seem to affect the structure.
I have woken up cold a couple of times in the Vango. I have never woken up cold in the Helsport. It seems to hold body heat better. I've used both tents on pretty cold nights; well into single digits, though I don't know exact temperatures. I've not been camping in winter conditions in recent years.
The only disadvantage of the HelSport is that it is hotter on a warm summer day. I don't spend much time in it on a warm sunny day, so that doesn't bother me particularly. It could be a significant disadvantage to someone who likes to have lay-ins
If I were buying a new tent, I'd get another Helsport.
“In some ways, it is easier to be a dissident, for then one is without responsibility.”
― Nelson Mandela, Long Walk to Freedom
― Nelson Mandela, Long Walk to Freedom
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
JackRabbitSlims wrote:Are there any other brands you could suggest that I look at at other than the Hille or Helsport?
I'm looking for a freestander for sure
Not seen one in the flesh, but on paper at least the Robens Raptor ticks the boxes I like to see ticked.
Often seen riding a bike around Dundee...
-
- Posts: 3
- Joined: 21 Sep 2018, 1:49pm
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
Love my MSR Hubba Hubba 2person and I see it a lot on Bicycle tour insta.
Loads of room and dual entry, it also can be used on solid ground as no tent pegs are mandatory
Loads of room and dual entry, it also can be used on solid ground as no tent pegs are mandatory
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
Keepingtheoldmanout wrote:Love my MSR Hubba Hubba 2person and I see it a lot on Bicycle tour insta.
Loads of room and dual entry, it also can be used on solid ground as no tent pegs are mandatory
Kind of... it's "self supporting" rather than "free standing" because the porches need pegging out to pitch it properly. You can sort of get by without doing that, but the material would just hang there like ill fitting curtains.
Pete.
Often seen riding a bike around Dundee...
Re: Advice required on choice of 2/3 person lightweight tent
pjclinch wrote:Keepingtheoldmanout wrote:Love my MSR Hubba Hubba 2person and I see it a lot on Bicycle tour insta.
Loads of room and dual entry, it also can be used on solid ground as no tent pegs are mandatory
Kind of... it's "self supporting" rather than "free standing" because the porches need pegging out to pitch it properly. You can sort of get by without doing that, but the material would just hang there like ill fitting curtains.
Pete.
Yes my robens lodge 2 is like that. Not a complaint - it's an excellently designed tent.
Sweep