Cartridge bottom Brackets
Cartridge bottom Brackets
Now that Shimano UN55 BBs seem to be thin on the ground I'm wondering what the options are, specifically in my case 68mm x 122.5mm. Plenty of cheap options but I doubt their long term reliability, particularly on the back of a tandem! Spa Cycles list Shimano UN300 and Stronglight JP400. What are the panel's thoughts?
Last edited by iandusud on 17 Jun 2021, 9:18pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 2918
- Joined: 9 Jun 2008, 8:06pm
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
The UN300 is mediocre. People have had them fail already and they are very different inside. Shimano trying to kill off ST (the UN5x was the cheap and heavy range already, the UN9x and UN7x being long gone; even the UN54 still had a hollow axle).
Tange-Seiki are ok, in the "two cups, two cartridge bearings and a sleeve" style. I've had no issues with Token, either. Avoid Genetic Karyotype - if you tighten the cups sufficiently to secure them, the carbon sleeve compresses and the bearings bind.
Tange-Seiki are ok, in the "two cups, two cartridge bearings and a sleeve" style. I've had no issues with Token, either. Avoid Genetic Karyotype - if you tighten the cups sufficiently to secure them, the carbon sleeve compresses and the bearings bind.
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
Do all things Shimano still have a 2 year guarantee? If so you could buy a UN300 and take it back every time it fails. Maybe they’d get the message then too.
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I’m sure I’ve got a new one in the stash.
Remember folks 'A pessimist is just an optimist with experience!'
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I think the Stronglight JP400 and (some/all) Miche bottom brackets are made by Kinex in Slovakia. I have not seen a picture of one dismantled, but it looks like a superior design to the UN300 and similar designs. Rather than a central sleeve between two cartridge bearings with the usual small balls, the sleeve covers the bearings. It looks therefore like the bearings are not cartridges, but larger ball bearings with a race on the axle. They might therefore be comparable to the UN55/UN26, depending upon the quality of the seals.
On a general note, it seems that the question of what square taper bottom bracket to buy now that the UN55 has been discontinued is going to keep resulting in new threads being started. We've aready had one lengthy thread on this issue - viewtopic.php?f=5&t=141038, and more recently this one - viewtopic.php?f=5&t=146281. It might be worth merging these threads to keep this sort of information on one thread.
Stronglight JP400
Kinex
On a general note, it seems that the question of what square taper bottom bracket to buy now that the UN55 has been discontinued is going to keep resulting in new threads being started. We've aready had one lengthy thread on this issue - viewtopic.php?f=5&t=141038, and more recently this one - viewtopic.php?f=5&t=146281. It might be worth merging these threads to keep this sort of information on one thread.
Stronglight JP400
Kinex
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
Another one to avoid: First Components F-2001P. This was recommended to me by a well known touring bike shop partly because the plastic cups won't corrode. However, the drive side cup split, my bike became unrideable and I had to phone for rescue in the middle of a big ride.
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I'm reasonably optimistic about UN300.rogerzilla wrote: ↑17 Jun 2021, 3:24pm The UN300 is mediocre. People have had them fail already and they are very different inside. Shimano trying to kill off ST (the UN5x was the cheap and heavy range already, the UN9x and UN7x being long gone; even the UN54 still had a hollow axle).
Tange-Seiki are ok, in the "two cups, two cartridge bearings and a sleeve" style. I've had no issues with Token, either. Avoid Genetic Karyotype - if you tighten the cups sufficiently to secure them, the carbon sleeve compresses and the bearings bind.
True, its a "2 cups, 2 cartridge bearings, and a sleeve" offering. like so many others.
However, the Shimano cups have a grease seal in each side, and its fairly straightforward to introduce some grease between the cups and the cartridge bearing. viewtopic.php?f=5&t=105385&start=15....this may not extend the life of the bearing greatly, but its unlikely to do any harm.
I doubt that UN300 will last as well as UN5x, but I don't know why they would be measurably inferior to all the other similar units?
Bike fitting D.I.Y. .....http://wheel-easy.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/bike-set-up-2017a.pdf
Tracks in the Dales etc...http://www.flickr.com/photos/52358536@N06/collections/
Tracks in the Dales etc...http://www.flickr.com/photos/52358536@N06/collections/
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I had a JP400 kicking about in the shed for years.....it looks like I have thrown it away, just when it would be really useful to have one to cut up. Maybe I can scrounge one out of the shop scrap bin!slowster wrote: ↑17 Jun 2021, 9:17pm I think the Stronglight JP400 and (some/all) Miche bottom brackets are made by Kinex in Slovakia. I have not seen a picture of one dismantled, but it looks like a superior design to the UN300 and similar designs. Rather than a central sleeve between two cartridge bearings with the usual small balls, the sleeve covers the bearings. It looks therefore like the bearings are not cartridges, but larger ball bearings with a race on the axle. They might therefore be comparable to the UN55/UN26, depending upon the quality of the seals.......................
Bike fitting D.I.Y. .....http://wheel-easy.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/bike-set-up-2017a.pdf
Tracks in the Dales etc...http://www.flickr.com/photos/52358536@N06/collections/
Tracks in the Dales etc...http://www.flickr.com/photos/52358536@N06/collections/
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
My experience with Kinex bottom brackets has not been favourable. Link here to the internals. Note how few balls there are and how small they have to be. In my experience they have a short lifespan.
search.php?keywords=Kinex&t=141038&sf=msgonly
search.php?keywords=Kinex&t=141038&sf=msgonly
At the last count:- Peugeot 531 pro, Dawes Discovery Tandem, Dawes Kingpin X3, Raleigh 20 stowaway X2, 1965 Moulton deluxe, Falcon K2 MTB dropped bar tourer, Rudge Bi frame folder, Longstaff trike conversion on a Giant XTC 840
- SimonCelsa
- Posts: 1235
- Joined: 6 Apr 2011, 10:19pm
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I've had continued good use out of the Neco brand from SJS:
https://www.sjscycles.co.uk/bottom-brac ... sh-thread/
You can't get much cheaper than that!!
Fitted 2 x 122.5mm to a tandem (needed the longer axle for an electric hub conversion). Admittedly only seen a couple of thousand mile usage but problem free so far. Unfortunately it appears that SJS are getting low on stock.
https://www.sjscycles.co.uk/bottom-brac ... sh-thread/
You can't get much cheaper than that!!
Fitted 2 x 122.5mm to a tandem (needed the longer axle for an electric hub conversion). Admittedly only seen a couple of thousand mile usage but problem free so far. Unfortunately it appears that SJS are getting low on stock.
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I fitted a JP400 to a recumbent recently. It certainly had the look and feel of a quality BB. It rotated freely both before and after installation, better than the UN55s I have handled recently.
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I'm not clear from your linked piece whether your dis-assembly of the unit was destructive or non-destructive?rjb wrote: ↑17 Jun 2021, 10:40pm My experience with Kinex bottom brackets has not been favourable. Link here to the internals. Note how few balls there are and how small they have to be. In my experience they have a short lifespan.
search.php?keywords=Kinex&t=141038&sf=msgonly
If I could dismantle the unit sufficiently to (annually?) add a decent quantity of good grease with corrosion inhibitors and re-assemble it without damage, that might be a good trade-off for reduced bearing numbers/size?
Bike fitting D.I.Y. .....http://wheel-easy.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/bike-set-up-2017a.pdf
Tracks in the Dales etc...http://www.flickr.com/photos/52358536@N06/collections/
Tracks in the Dales etc...http://www.flickr.com/photos/52358536@N06/collections/
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I destroyed a Token in two MTB singlespeeding winters. There is a design weakness: the cup is a water trap allowing water past the seal into the bearing. The splines are shallow too. Typically I got 30,000-50,000 miles from a UN-7x.
I've now bought a Genetic Karyotype (around £40) which has the nice hollow axle like the superb UN-7x of old. Weight 220g (103mm). Fingers crossed it's more durable.
I've now bought a Genetic Karyotype (around £40) which has the nice hollow axle like the superb UN-7x of old. Weight 220g (103mm). Fingers crossed it's more durable.
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
I could have reassembled it but the reason I took it apart was idle curiosity. It had developed significant play in the bearings and when dismantled there was significant pitting of the axle races. The seal had probably let water past it although there wasn't much sign of contaminated grease internally. If you can remove the seal without damaging it and get more grease or even semi fluid grease inside it may well prolong its life. Good luck to anyone who attempts this. Let us all know how you get on.531colin wrote: ↑18 Jun 2021, 10:14amI'm not clear from your linked piece whether your dis-assembly of the unit was destructive or non-destructive?rjb wrote: ↑17 Jun 2021, 10:40pm My experience with Kinex bottom brackets has not been favourable. Link here to the internals. Note how few balls there are and how small they have to be. In my experience they have a short lifespan.
search.php?keywords=Kinex&t=141038&sf=msgonly
If I could dismantle the unit sufficiently to (annually?) add a decent quantity of good grease with corrosion inhibitors and re-assemble it without damage, that might be a good trade-off for reduced bearing numbers/size?
At the last count:- Peugeot 531 pro, Dawes Discovery Tandem, Dawes Kingpin X3, Raleigh 20 stowaway X2, 1965 Moulton deluxe, Falcon K2 MTB dropped bar tourer, Rudge Bi frame folder, Longstaff trike conversion on a Giant XTC 840
-
- Posts: 417
- Joined: 5 Feb 2017, 11:58am
Re: Cartridge bottom Brackets
This Tandem seller has Tange as well as as the Shimano UN55. I realise Tange was mentioned earlier in the thread so I guess this would backup that suggestion.
https://www.tandems.co.uk/m8b0s56p0/Com ... m-Brackets
They seem to have stock of the UN55 though.
https://www.tandems.co.uk/m8b0s56p0/Com ... m-Brackets
They seem to have stock of the UN55 though.