531ST - Claud Butler v Galaxy

[bikes4two]

Having not experienced drops on a tourer nor a steel frame, I'm currently looking for a used tourer with drops and a 531 (or better) frame.

Galaxies seem thin on the ground at the moment but I have the chance to acquire a Claud Butler Black Diamond (apparently made exclusively for SJS Cycles some years ago.)

Is anyone in a position to comment on the relatives merits of the Claud Butler and the Galaxy as I would be grateful for your views - thanks.

[York Commuter]

I've no experience of the CB Black Diamond, but having looked at the one advertised on eBay at the moment I would have no qualms about buying one if the "price were right" according to condition etc.

But as with all things ride it if you can, and if it feels right etc buy it - donb't miss out on pleasure by looking for months for for a Galaxy when the Diamond could have given you that pleasure.

Stephen

[CREPELLO]

As long as it's built by a reputable builder, any 531 tourer will almost certainly do what you require. I'm suprised you say Galaxies are thin on the ground - they're the most common off peg tourer, certainly of the lugged variety. If you are looking pon Ebay, you'll find they're like buses - you can wait for ages, then three that you want will come along at the same time.
They are a little over rated IMO, mainly because the go for a premium price over most of the competition, but also build quality varied a lot in the final years of Brum production. Having said that, I'm building one up at the momment to sell, so if I could interest you in a 2000 Super Gal in silver, 23.5" frame, rebuilt wheels in excellent condition, give us a PM.

[bikes4two]

Thanks Crepello - PM sent

[mercurykev]

I use to have a 531ST Black Diamond and a 531ST Super Galaxy and I actually thought that Black Diamond had a nicer frame. It was well finished, the clearances were better and very sturdy.

[bikes4two]

Hi Mercurykev,
Does 'very sturdy' also equate to 'heavy'? Were they of equal weight or one much heavier than the other? Any other observations about touring abilities, reliability etc?

[mercurykev]

Hi Mercurykev,
Does 'very sturdy' also equate to 'heavy'? Were they of equal weight or one much heavier than the other? Any other observations about touring abilities, reliability etc?

There wasn't much of a difference in weight between the two bikes. By sturdy, I was more meaning sure footed/stable.