Bonefishblues wrote:Cunobelin wrote:Bonefishblues wrote:Well it would be if we could be sure that the survey method was reliable, yes. Then as you rightly say, we'd have to turn our attention to the way in which it had been used.
As I indicated in a reply to ano above, we must be careful to apply the same scrutiny to everything we forward to support or challenge something.
Nope..... The thing to do is treat others like adults.
Rather than perform. critical review of the research methodology of any article before posting... post it and assume that most others on here can form an opinion of their own.
Our view differs then. I don't post things without looking critically at whether they actually support a point I'm making.
Which goes back to the start, I did and it does...... please discuss your problems with the authors