workhard wrote:Dee Jay wrote:Oooh! I didn't realise I was in the company of so many other fans of The Cure on here! Excellent!
So what is your take on the multiple covers of "Just like Heaven" that seem to jump out of every Radio 2 and Radio 6 programme I listen to?
Hi, Workhard!
Well, I'm assuming that Radio 2 is playing the Katie Melua version and that Radio 6 is playing the Dinosaur Jr version and that there aren't any others I've missed.
I first heard Katie's version several months ago, when my gym instructor played it for the 'cool-down' ... and I thought: blimey; not heard that version before! Not really a fan of KM, although she does have very pretty voice. For me, her cover - although a still very obviously a lovesong - does not go anywhere near capturing the dark, vampyric, lovelorn romantiscism of the original.
I've heard Dinosaur Jr's cover a couple of times - allegedly this version is Robert Smith's favourite cover of this song - and although it's fun, it's rock 'n' roll ... I also think that it's pastiche. (Which is probably why RS likes it?) Dinosaur Jr: are they American? For me, they've removed all that English whimsy, which, of course, defines The Cure, and they've just left the song. But, of course, this is the only way to cover
any song: don't sound anything like the original. If you can't bring a freshness to a song, walk away from it.
Fortunately it is an excellent song and this is why it is difficult to do a bad cover: the material just does it all.
You're sorry you asked now, aren't you?
We should take this to a Cure appreciation thread!