BEVs

Use this board for general non-cycling-related chat, or to introduce yourself to the forum.

I appreciate the BEV mostly because they...

cost less to run than an equivalent petrol or diesel car
9
12%
are reducing the harm done to our planet and its lifeforms
11
14%
are quiet and smooth
7
9%
can be refuelled with my own renewable energy production
10
13%
can supply energy to the home and Grid
4
5%
No! I am concerned they are just another way of making the car seem acceptable
35
46%
 
Total votes: 76

User avatar
Cugel
Posts: 6197
Joined: 13 Nov 2017, 11:14am

Re: BEVs

Post by Cugel »

Biospace wrote: 6 Aug 2024, 11:46am
Cugel wrote: 6 Aug 2024, 11:29am ...
A lot of reported truth is in fact constructed propaganda.
...
A lot of unreported facts also help construct propaganda, in a more subtle manner which is more difficult to expose.

I agree it's a slippery slope and the West has hardly led by example in recent times, but one powerful example for our relatively successful societies in the West is that of our relative freedoms of expression, speech and movement. Let good argument have space to germinate fresh ideas which can be freely debated, without concern for Big Brother looking over your shoulder.
Is there no case for a Big Brother then? I know that the 1984 one was a bit of a fascist nutter but there can be, can there not, a sort of benevolent dictatorship that denies some free speech types to allow other free speech types. (E.g. denying the right to incite the burning of a library allows others to read and comment on what is in that library). ANd, after all, we already do have the laws of libel & slander, for example: applied by that big brother Parliament via the other brothers & sisters in the justice system.

How about the sort of free speech and associated behaviours we've seen of late in various large towns and cities? Is there no case for a Big Brother there? Myself, I'd like to see an even bigger one than that currently available. ..... Just not the sort that those rioters would enjoy - Tommy Rotterscum or Farago The Destroyer, for example, in uniforms of brown and black with death's heads on 'em!

Perhaps what I'm really in favour of is a strict nanny. :-)
“Practical men who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence are usually the slaves of some defunct economist”.
John Maynard Keynes
Biospace
Posts: 2681
Joined: 24 Jun 2019, 12:23pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Biospace »

Cugel wrote: 6 Aug 2024, 4:28pm
Is there no case for a Big Brother then? I know that the 1984 one was a bit of a fascist nutter but there can be, can there not, a sort of benevolent dictatorship that denies some free speech types to allow other free speech types.
...
Isn't that pretty much what we can appear to be, this century, as principles of the latter 19th into 20th centuries, built upon the foundations of the Scientific Revolution and Age of Enlightenment, give way to our reactions to the 21st century world.

If a nation is at one in appreciating and respecting how "Free Speech" has eventual boundaries, acting with courtesy and respect for others while still articulating thoughts and feelings, chaos is generally avoided. If freedoms of speech are unnecessarily restricted for weak reasons and in attempts to prevent embarrassment or awkwardness, either chaos or totalitarianism will ensue, as sure as night follows day.

As Orwell said, "If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear." There have been times this century when I've begun to realise just how fragile and temporary the democratic world we've inherited from our forebears may be.
ossie
Posts: 1803
Joined: 15 Apr 2011, 7:52pm

Re: BEVs

Post by ossie »

Biospace wrote: 6 Aug 2024, 11:36am
Jdsk wrote: 5 Aug 2024, 8:40pm Discussion of today's figures for sales of new cars:

SMMT:
"Battery electric vehicle uptake outpaces overall market, up 18.8%, but remains behind mandated transition trajectory."
https://x.com/SMMT/status/1820371609862938767
...
Jonathan
The figures quoted are for July, perhaps helpful to those who follow such numbers assiduously and know exactly what to expect for any given month (fleet sales may concentrate at particular times of the year or the release of a new car may skew the figures, for example) but for most of us, the more indicative figures are those spread over the last year.

For the year to date, the increases (H stands for hybrid) are:
  • 10.5% for BEVs
  • 28.2% for PHEV
  • 17.1% for HEV
It's worth bearing in mind that these figures are less demand-led than usual since the supply is now being controlled by Government diktat, with a minimum of 22% "Zero Emission Vehicles" sold through 2024, https://www.whatcar.com/advice/buying/w ... ate/n26196

There is also the consideration that in times of economic hardship, fleet sales are likely to account for a greater proportion of new car sales.
Yes, fleet / company sales in relation to BEV dominate due to BIK, very few private buyers for new BEV due to massive depreciation - if you're private and want new consider lease. Dealers are also registering BEV's in an effort to meet the Govt quota, this will result in lower prices for basically new vehicles when they start filling forecourts.

The used BEV market need fleet / lease vehicles to trickle down but there's so much distrust amongst buyers. Not so with hybrid, where although Toyota were criticised for not going full EV they clearly 'read the room' hence the figures.

The best way to look at BEV is simply that's in an alternative way of fuelling a vehicle at the moment and no more.
Biospace
Posts: 2681
Joined: 24 Jun 2019, 12:23pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Biospace »

ossie wrote: 6 Aug 2024, 9:33pm Yes, fleet / company sales in relation to BEV dominate due to BIK, very few private buyers for new BEV due to massive depreciation - if you're private and want new consider lease. Dealers are also registering BEV's in an effort to meet the Govt quota, this will result in lower prices for basically new vehicles when they start filling forecourts.

The used BEV market need fleet / lease vehicles to trickle down but there's so much distrust amongst buyers. Not so with hybrid, where although Toyota were criticised for not going full EV they clearly 'read the room' hence the figures.

The best way to look at BEV is simply that's in an alternative way of fuelling a vehicle at the moment and no more.
Toyota are probably the most intelligent car manufacturer on the planet, how they proceed should be of note to us all.

An alternative way of refuelling, yes, but with a limit on the number of refills and how long the 'fuel tank' will last. If you can afford the high upfront costs, an EV can save a lot of money with its tax benefits - on purchase price as well as fuel.
the snail
Posts: 387
Joined: 5 Aug 2011, 3:11pm

Re: BEVs

Post by the snail »

Biospace wrote: 7 Aug 2024, 2:38pm
Toyota are probably the most intelligent car manufacturer on the planet, how they proceed should be of note to us all.

Hardly, they spent years pushing the Hydrogen Mirai, which never made any sense, and they are pushing hybrids which are a dead-end technology. They are living on their reputation, but really their record in recent years has been poor and they are living on borrowed time. Companies like Tesla, BYD, Zeekr are way ahead of them.
User avatar
Cowsham
Posts: 5607
Joined: 4 Nov 2019, 1:33pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Cowsham »

the snail wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 12:24am
Biospace wrote: 7 Aug 2024, 2:38pm
Toyota are probably the most intelligent car manufacturer on the planet, how they proceed should be of note to us all.

Hardly, they spent years pushing the Hydrogen Mirai, which never made any sense, and they are pushing hybrids which are a dead-end technology. They are living on their reputation, but really their record in recent years has been poor and they are living on borrowed time. Companies like Tesla, BYD, Zeekr are way ahead of them.
They've gone full battery car now.
Last edited by Cowsham on 8 Aug 2024, 10:57am, edited 1 time in total.
I am here. Where are you?
Carlton green
Posts: 4159
Joined: 22 Jun 2019, 12:27pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Carlton green »

the snail wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 12:24am
Biospace wrote: 7 Aug 2024, 2:38pm
Toyota are probably the most intelligent car manufacturer on the planet, how they proceed should be of note to us all.

Hardly, they spent years pushing the Hydrogen Mirai, which never made any sense, and they are pushing hybrids which are a dead-end technology. They are living on their reputation, but really their record in recent years has been poor and they are living on borrowed time. Companies like Tesla, BYD, Zeekr are way ahead of them.

Toyota has become one of the world’s largest and best-known automobile manufacturing businesses
https://www.toyota-europe.com/about-us/ ... -the-world

As per posts further up the thread hybrid vehicles are selling rather well and looking at the range that Toyota sell Hydrogen powered vehicles are a small part of it.
https://www.toyota.co.uk/gad_source=1&g ... lsrc=aw.ds
https://x.com/SMMT/status/1820371609862938767

I’d suggest to you that Toyota have a far better understanding of motor vehicles, business and the future than you give them credit for …
Last edited by Carlton green on 8 Aug 2024, 8:49am, edited 1 time in total.
Don’t fret, it’s OK to: ride a simple old bike; ride slowly, walk, rest and admire the view; ride off-road; ride in your raincoat; ride by yourself; ride in the dark; and ride one hundred yards or one hundred miles. Your bike and your choices to suit you.
francovendee
Posts: 3336
Joined: 5 May 2009, 6:32am

Re: BEVs

Post by francovendee »

Maybe it's because people trust old tech more but the value of hybrid Toyota cars remain very high as opposed to something like a Zoe of the same mileage and distance.
I think it will take a few more years before buyers in the main immediately think of BEV when it's time to change their car.
When the range of any 6 yo BEV is the same as half a tank of fuel in an IC we'll all be buying them.
Yes I know most journeys are far less but it's the convenience of petrol/diesel.
It was this convenience that won the day over the steam car. People are lazy and don't want to be plugging a car in every 100 miles or so.
Fuel prices will have to double at least before the cost outweighs the advantage of their IC car.
Biospace
Posts: 2681
Joined: 24 Jun 2019, 12:23pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Biospace »

the snail wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 12:24am
Biospace wrote: 7 Aug 2024, 2:38pm Toyota are probably the most intelligent car manufacturer on the planet, how they proceed should be of note to us all.
Hardly...
I can only state my own opinion; that they didn't go head over heels chasing battery only powered cars ten years ago is perhaps an indication of the opposite of intelligence in your opinion, for many others Toyota have the very best minds in the business who didn't reckon on the herd-like behaviour of Western governments in promising to compel nothing other than these "Zero Emission" :?: vehicles.
User avatar
Cowsham
Posts: 5607
Joined: 4 Nov 2019, 1:33pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Cowsham »

francovendee wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 8:44am Maybe it's because people trust old tech more but the value of hybrid Toyota cars remain very high as opposed to something like a Zoe of the same mileage and distance.
I think it will take a few more years before buyers in the main immediately think of BEV when it's time to change their car.
When the range of any 6 yo BEV is the same as half a tank of fuel in an IC we'll all be buying them.
Yes I know most journeys are far less but it's the convenience of petrol/diesel.
It was this convenience that won the day over the steam car. People are lazy and don't want to be plugging a car in every 100 miles or so.
Fuel prices will have to double at least before the cost outweighs the advantage of their IC car.
It's when they go to the petrol station and there's no petrol that'll be the shocker.
I am here. Where are you?
Biospace
Posts: 2681
Joined: 24 Jun 2019, 12:23pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Biospace »

francovendee wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 8:44am Maybe it's because people trust old tech more but the value of hybrid Toyota cars remain very high as opposed to something like a Zoe of the same mileage and distance.
I think it will take a few more years before buyers in the main immediately think of BEV when it's time to change their car.
When the range of any 6 yo BEV is the same as half a tank of fuel in an IC we'll all be buying them.
Yes I know most journeys are far less but it's the convenience of petrol/diesel.
It was this convenience that won the day over the steam car. People are lazy and don't want to be plugging a car in every 100 miles or so.
Fuel prices will have to double at least before the cost outweighs the advantage of their IC car.
I'm not convinced it is mostly the lack of convenience which is leaving buyers sceptical, especially in households with more than one car looking to replace the second car - it's quite possibly the cost and potential costs down the line. There's little more convenient for a daily use short to medium hop vehicle than one which is preheated/precooled and which "just works", is more comfortable, quieter, more accelerative and costs much less to run and service.

The second hand car market is several times larger than the new one and there are concerns once a car is over a certain age that the battery will cost many thousands to repair or replace, or that depreciation is so great that it cancels out savings in use. More experience of how the batteries behave as the miles and years pile on will make choices easier.

This hesistancy likely cascades up the market, so that reduced demand when BEV values drop towards and into four figures speeds up the depreciation, giving those selling less money towards a new car and prompting the question as to whether or not to buy another BEV.

When the electric car market was made of primarily of early adopters and eco-enthusiasts, the knowledge was present and so uncertainties much smaller, but with adoption by the mass market (in part using Covid money printing), volatility is more likely, as we're seeing.

But yes, I agree that once an older and cheaper BEV will easily cover 150 miles on a single charge and the batteries are seen to be sufficiently stable in their deterioration that the risk is no greater than an engine "blowing up", few will want a car with an engine.

Cowsham wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 10:59am It's when they go to the petrol station and there's no petrol that'll be the shocker.
Given how people started stockpiling it in their garden sheds and even house roofspaces when previously in short supply, I'm not sure a Government would wish to replay that scenario, instead I'd expect the price to rise more than it has over the last decade.

Many contemporary cars with engines are so complex, expensive to maintain and not as long lasting compared with what went before, I don't think there will be many who hang on unnecessarily, especially when the cheaper BEVs we're promised hit the second hand markets outside of main dealers' forecourts.

For the consumer, there's not much not to like about battery powered cars compared with many petrol/diesel cars sold over the last few years.
User avatar
Cowsham
Posts: 5607
Joined: 4 Nov 2019, 1:33pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Cowsham »

Biospace wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 11:23am For the consumer, there's not much not to like about battery powered cars compared with many petrol/diesel cars sold over the last few years.
And for the cyclist as they go past. I had to stop yesterday, as a very Smokey diesel went past, to let the fumes get down to the ground before I carried on.
I am here. Where are you?
Biospace
Posts: 2681
Joined: 24 Jun 2019, 12:23pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Biospace »

Cowsham wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 12:33pm
Biospace wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 11:23am For the consumer, there's not much not to like about battery powered cars compared with many petrol/diesel cars sold over the last few years.
And for the cyclist as they go past. I had to stop yesterday, as a very Smokey diesel went past, to let the fumes get down to the ground before I carried on.
Yes, if modern cars had tailpipe emissions the same as 25 years ago then cycling would be as unpleasant (or more) now as it was then.

The occasional vehicle with a dirty exhaust now stands out like a sore thumb, although it's depressing that many vehicles in near constant use such as delivery vans are often older, more polluting diesels, while low mileage Grannies have been pushed into buying new cars.

This transfer of technology could have been managed better, if it's emissions we're trying to reduce. All the while, air travel continues largely unimpeded, there are power stations to be built by Microsoft and Amazon running on fossil fuel near Dublin (diesel generators and gas) to power the insatiable rise for data - while it's the individual who is penalised for acquiring a battery powered car.

https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/n ... in-dublin/
https://www.techerati.com/news-hub/micr ... -approved/
the snail
Posts: 387
Joined: 5 Aug 2011, 3:11pm

Re: BEVs

Post by the snail »

Biospace wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 10:48am
the snail wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 12:24am
Biospace wrote: 7 Aug 2024, 2:38pm Toyota are probably the most intelligent car manufacturer on the planet, how they proceed should be of note to us all.
Hardly...
I can only state my own opinion; that they didn't go head over heels chasing battery only powered cars ten years ago is perhaps an indication of the opposite of intelligence in your opinion, for many others Toyota have the very best minds in the business who didn't reckon on the herd-like behaviour of Western governments in promising to compel nothing other than these "Zero Emission" :?: vehicles.
Why did they spend all that time making a Hydrogen car, when it never made any sense? Because they were chasing subsidy, certainly not an engineering driven strategy. If they're so smart, why did they fail to develop the hybrid technology so that now they have to buy it from BYD. And why have they had to B.S. about their battery technology, only to now go to BYD? They had a good reputation a decade ago, but they seem to on a downward path towards becoming the next Kodak.
Biospace
Posts: 2681
Joined: 24 Jun 2019, 12:23pm

Re: BEVs

Post by Biospace »

It does appear that ever more data use (have you seen the predicted rise in carbon emissions for this alone?), air travel and electricity consumption (which will continue to consume vast quantities of fossil fuel for a few decades yet, even in Britain) seem to feature far less in our politicians' concerns for the heating planet than other forms of pollutions, despite their increasing emissions.

A comment on YouTube recently said, "I think the politicians came up with an answer before thinking about what they wanted to achieve."

the snail wrote: 8 Aug 2024, 2:24pm Why did they spend all that time making a Hydrogen car, when it never made any sense? Because they were chasing subsidy, certainly not an engineering driven strategy. If they're so smart, why did they fail to develop the hybrid technology so that now they have to buy it from BYD. And why have they had to B.S. about their battery technology, only to now go to BYD? They had a good reputation a decade ago, but they seem to on a downward path towards becoming the next Kodak.
Possibly, but I stand by my remark that they're the most intelligent motor manufacturer. And BYD is a battery manufacturing specialist, more recently they also make cars. If any large name is heading Kodak's way, it more likely to be Ford or even VW.
Post Reply