Spiking heart rate monitor issues
-
- Posts: 625
- Joined: 22 May 2022, 12:53pm
Spiking heart rate monitor issues
I have a Magene chest strap HR monitor. I bought it in May and it's been very reliable, with about 7000km of trouble free use.
I replaced the battery a couple of months back, but just lately (last few weeks) it's started reading high sometimes, with HR spikes that are obviously false.
Does anyone have any experience with this? Is it a case of needing to clean up contacts? Replace battery? Or just a HR monitor in need of replacement?
It's quite annoying, as being a numbers nerd, I like the metrics that come from having it.
I replaced the battery a couple of months back, but just lately (last few weeks) it's started reading high sometimes, with HR spikes that are obviously false.
Does anyone have any experience with this? Is it a case of needing to clean up contacts? Replace battery? Or just a HR monitor in need of replacement?
It's quite annoying, as being a numbers nerd, I like the metrics that come from having it.
-
- Posts: 3996
- Joined: 26 Mar 2022, 7:13am
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
How can you be sure the numbers are false?
Bit of an OTT comparison, but Chernobyl happened partly because the guys in the control room decided that the figures from the instruments were unbelievable and a symptom of an instrumentation error.
Bit of an OTT comparison, but Chernobyl happened partly because the guys in the control room decided that the figures from the instruments were unbelievable and a symptom of an instrumentation error.
-
- Posts: 625
- Joined: 22 May 2022, 12:53pm
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
Thanks Jonathan. I'll give it a read.
-
- Posts: 625
- Joined: 22 May 2022, 12:53pm
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
It's a fairly recent occurrence. I'm had nearly 300hrs of using this HR monitor so I'm quite experienced in knowing how my heart now responds to training input. My HR maximum, prior to this tech issue, was 185bpm, and that genuinely feels close to my max and was on an all out hill climb. I'm also 38, so it roughly aligns with the rule of thumb (220 minus age).Nearholmer wrote: ↑29 Jan 2023, 8:41am How can you be sure the numbers are false?
Bit of an OTT comparison, but Chernobyl happened partly because the guys in the control room decided that the figures from the instruments were unbelievable and a symptom of an instrumentation error.
I saw 196bpm on Friday whilst steadily pedalling up a gentle incline. It's not an accurate measurement.
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
Sounds like battery contacts.
Have we got time for another cuppa?
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
Do you have any reason to think that it might be a genuine clinical problem... detectable rhythm disturbances, pain, feeling faint... ?
Jonathan
Jonathan
-
- Posts: 3996
- Joined: 26 Mar 2022, 7:13am
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
Strange “butterfly” sensation? Can be very subtle indeed.
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
I had similar issues with a Wahoo Tickr chest strap, both spikes and very low readings. I resorted to using electrode gel on the chest contacts and it's been fine since. I think mine was likely caused by not enough sweat to keep the contacts wet in the winter.
-
- Posts: 625
- Joined: 22 May 2022, 12:53pm
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
No, nothing at all. The spikes tend to be when I'm not exerting myself particularly.
I'm increasingly thinking that it's a contact issue. The two rides where it's been particularly noticeable have been lower intensity rides at low temperature. Perhaps a lack of sweat.
The electrode gel is a good call. I wonder if (in the meantime) whether vaseline might work too?
-
- Posts: 7898
- Joined: 7 Mar 2009, 3:31pm
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
Jon in Sweden wrote: ↑29 Jan 2023, 11:01am
The electrode gel is a good call. I wonder if (in the meantime) whether vaseline might work too?
https://www.bioshare.info/en/diygelConductive gel: Just mix a tiny pinch of table salt, into your favorite gel (aloe vera gel is nice), and you are done (see link below). A little (5~10cc) can go a long way. It's really not that critical if the salt amount is a bit more or a bit less. If you like, adding a few drops of shampoo can help with oily skins too. The conductive gel is very easy to clean up, just wash off with water.
It's the same the whole world over
It's the poor what gets the blame
It's the rich what gets the pleasure
Isn't it a blooming shame?
It's the poor what gets the blame
It's the rich what gets the pleasure
Isn't it a blooming shame?
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
ThanksJon in Sweden wrote: ↑29 Jan 2023, 11:01amNo, nothing at all. The spikes tend to be when I'm not exerting myself particularly.
...
Yes, it sounds like an artefact.
Jonathan
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
More than likely contacts and IME especially in cold weather.
In the last 30 yrs I’ve had a Garmin, aWahoo, a Scosche and currently a Polar H10.
The first two the straps got tired and experienced spikes as they got older. The Scosche was completely useless and eventually got a full refund for it. It spiked on every descent
The current H10 is the best I’ve had, easily makes contact, comfortable to wear, never misses a beat. I do now follow care instructions and wash it after every few rides. I’m guilty of not doing that with those early purchases.
In the last 30 yrs I’ve had a Garmin, aWahoo, a Scosche and currently a Polar H10.
The first two the straps got tired and experienced spikes as they got older. The Scosche was completely useless and eventually got a full refund for it. It spiked on every descent
The current H10 is the best I’ve had, easily makes contact, comfortable to wear, never misses a beat. I do now follow care instructions and wash it after every few rides. I’m guilty of not doing that with those early purchases.
Whatever I am, wherever I am, this is me. This is my life
https://stcleve.wordpress.com/category/lejog/
E2E info
https://stcleve.wordpress.com/category/lejog/
E2E info
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
I wouldn't expect petroleum jelly to be sufficiently conductive, with or without added salt.Jon in Sweden wrote: ↑29 Jan 2023, 11:01am ...
The electrode gel is a good call. I wonder if (in the meantime) whether vaseline might work too?
Jonathan
Re: Spiking heart rate monitor issues
I think you'll find that Vaseline may well be an insulator it is also hydrophobic so will keep sweat away from the contacts.Jon in Sweden wrote: ↑29 Jan 2023, 11:01am
The electrode gel is a good call. I wonder if (in the meantime) whether vaseline might work too?
I like the sound of Mike's DIY gel as the electrode gel is a bit messy if it gets on your clothes. But as a little goes a long way I think my tube will last me years.